Foams
Material properties and characteristics relevant to foam selection and fabrication in P&O.
Foams are used in P&O for skin protection and for posting alignment. They may be adhered (i.e., glued) to the orthosis/prosthesis or formed over a model. Examples include prosthetic foam liners (i.e., pelite liners), foot orthoses, fracture orthoses, Charcot boots (CROW), and spinal orthoses. When selecting foams, consider the following:
- Cellular Structure Properties
- Cell Type and Size Open-cell foams allow air and fluid flow through interconnected pores, making them breathable. Closed-cell foams trap gas in isolated cells, providing buoyancy, thermal insulation, and moisture resistance. Cell size affects surface area, permeability, and mechanical properties. Most foams used in P&O are closed cell foams.
- Pros: do not soak up body fluids and provide more resistance to compression than open cell foams.
- Cons: not breathable, i.e., hot
- Cell Type and Size Open-cell foams allow air and fluid flow through interconnected pores, making them breathable. Closed-cell foams trap gas in isolated cells, providing buoyancy, thermal insulation, and moisture resistance. Cell size affects surface area, permeability, and mechanical properties. Most foams used in P&O are closed cell foams.
- Mechanical Properties
- Durometer and compression deflection
- Durometer: The most commonly used mechanical property used to select foams in P&O.
- Compression set and resilience
- Compression set: Low compression set better for long term use. Especially for weight bearing materials, we want the material to return to its original shape after prolonged compression.
- Resilience: Another way to think about compressibility, measured differently.
- Elongation, tensile strength, and tear strength
- Elongation: Consider the type of load that the foam will experience. Elongation is a tensile measurement.
-
Tensile strength is also measured during a tensile test, where the maximum stress the material can endure before breaking is recorded.
- Tear strength is an outcome of the tensile strength test.
- Abrasion resistance and coefficient of friction
- Abrasion Resistance: Important in selecting materials for high-wear environments, such as foot orthoses and areas of donning doffing.
- Coefficient of friction: Crucial in designing systems where sliding contact occurs, such as over scar tissue or immobile skin.
- Fatigue Resistance Critical for weight bearing applications.
- Hysteresis and Energy Absorption The difference between loading and unloading curves indicates energy dissipation capability, important for impact protection and vibration control.
- Durometer and compression deflection
- Processing and Fabrication Properties
- Adhesion Properties Bonding capability to substrates or other foam layers affects assembly methods and joint reliability.
- Machinability Ability to be cut, shaped, or machined without cell structure damage or excessive dust generation.
- Grindability: refers to the ease of modifying the foam on a grinder.
- Thermoformability: thermoplastic foams can be formed over a mold. Thermoset foams are not reformable.
- Molding temperature: the temperature that the foam can be reformed
- Physical and Other Properties
- Density
- Thickness Typical thickness of foams inside an orthosis or prosthesis are 3-5mm or 3/6″ thick. Thicker foams (1/2-1″) are use for posting or other buildups. Iron is a very old, yet traditional measurement in the shoe industry to measure the thickness of materials. One iron is equal to 1/48 inch (0.5292 millimeters), so, for example, a sole 1/4 inch thick is described as “12 iron”.
- Biocompatibility Designed to interact safely and effectively with living tissues
Material | Duometer (Shore A) |
Density (lb) |
Heating Time |
Heating Temp |
Grindable |
25% CFD (psi) |
Compression Set % |
Tensile Strength (psi) |
Elongation % |
Tear Strength (lb/in) |
Use in P&O |
Aliplast
(Alimed), Volara XPE aliplast (cross-linked PE foam) |
23 (white)
68 (XPE) |
2 12 |
|
250 F 325 F |
Yes |
5 50 |
|
|
|
Padding non-wt bearing
Low abrasion resistance Posting |
|
Pelite | 25-30 (med)
40-45 (firm) |
|
|
|
Yes |
|
|
|
|
Padding non-wt bearing
Prosthetic liners |
|
Plastizote | 20 (pink)
35 (firm) 65 (black) |
|
|
|
Yes |
|
|
|
|
Foot orthosis covers
Posting |
Material |
Duometer |
Density (lb) |
Heating Time |
Heating Temp (F) |
Grindable |
25% CFD (psi) |
Compression Set % |
Tensile Strength (psi) |
Elongation % |
Tear Strength (lb/in) |
Use in P&O |
P-Cell |
20 |
4.6 |
2-3 min |
225-275 |
Yes |
15.2 |
4.3 |
145.8 |
174.7 |
21.4 |
Wt bearing padding |
Microcel Puff 35 |
35 (Puff 35) 45 (Puff 45) 55 (Puff 55) |
7.1 9.2 12.1 |
2-3 min
4-5 min |
225-275
275-300 |
Yes |
35.5 47.3 55.3 |
3.8 4.5 7.1 |
209 297.6 340.5 |
139 119.4 125.5 |
31 44 53.2 |
Wt bearing shock absorption
Posting |
Puff FM |
65-70 (Puff FM) |
25.4 |
2-5 min |
275-300 |
Yes |
261.4 |
n/a |
580.8 |
161.5 |
116.4 |
Shoe buildups |
DuraForm |
|
13 |
2-3 min |
225-275 |
Yes |
25.5 |
3.7 |
331.2 |
208.9 |
42.5 |
|
MultiCork |
55-60 |
14.4 |
3-5 min |
275 |
Yes |
83.7 |
5.7 |
259.1 |
68.4 |
56 |
Posting |
SBR |
35 (SBR 35) 55 (SBR 55) |
7 116 |
2-3 min 4-5 min |
225-275 275-300 |
Yes |
31.6 68.2 |
3.8 4.8 |
211.8 333.6 |
115 124.5 |
30.1 47.5 |
|
Material |
Duometer (Shore A) |
Density (lb) |
Heating Time |
Heating Temp |
Grindable |
25% CFD (psi) |
Compression Set % |
Tensile Strength (psi) |
Elongation % |
Tear Strength (lb/in) |
Use in P&O |
Echocel Professional |
|
15-21 |
na |
na |
Yes |
12-18 |
3 max |
110 |
130 |
14.7 |
|
Echocel High Rebound |
|
17-23 |
na |
na |
Yes |
12-18 |
3 max |
70 |
130 |
14 |
|
Echocel Impact |
|
13-18 |
na |
na |
Yes |
4-9 |
3 max |
70 |
170 |
12 |
|
Echocel Slow Rebound |
|
8-12 |
na |
na |
Yes |
1-4 |
3 max |
50 |
190 |
8 |
|
Foams – Key Takeaways
- How to justify use of foams for P&O devices. Primary factors (in P&O) include:
- Cell type: open or closed
- Durometer and Compression deflection
- Machinability: Grindability, molding temperature
- Thermoformability: thermoform or thermoset
- Thickness
- Biocompatibility
- Density
- Thickness
Shore hardness is the property being measured, while the durometer is the tool used to measure it. However, we refer to the hardness as duromater, which is a material's resistance to indentation. Human Soft Tissue is about 20-25 Shore A.
The amount of deformation or displacement that occurs in a material when a compressive force is applied to it. Measures the average firmness across a large area of the material sample.
The permanent deformation that remains in a material after it has been compressed and the compressive force is removed. Low Compression Set Better for Long Term. Measured as a percentage of the original thickness that is not recovered after compression.
The ability of a material to absorb energy when it is deformed elastically and to release that energy upon unloading. Measured as the rebound height of a material is compressed and then allowed to recover.
The extent to which a material can be stretched or lengthened before it tears/breaks. Measured as a percentage of the original length as compared to the maximum strength length (tensile test).
The resistance to scuffing, scratching, wearing down, marring, or rubbing away.
The ratio between the force necessary to move one surface horizontally over another (shear) and the pressure between the two surfaces.
The ability to maintain properties under repeated loading cycles
A measurement of weight. Density (ρ) = Mass (m) / Volume (V).